The Untold Truth Of Joe Medicine Crow

Born in 1913 near Lodge Grass, Montana, Joe Medicine Crow grew up surrounded by vaunted Crow warriors, and he avidly soaked up their traditions (via Military). His paternal grandfather was Chief Medicine Crow, who first went into battle at 15 and would continue to see action until his last fight in 1877, per Little Big Horn College. According to the Public Broadcasting Service, his step-grandfather, White Man Runs Him, scouted for Lieutenant Colonel George Armstrong Custer at the Little Bighorn, providing firsthand accounts of the military blunders that precipitated the massacre.

His close connections with celebrated Crow warriors meant a unique early education by today's standards. Moving well beyond the ABCs and basic arithmetic, he mastered how to survive Montana's notoriously frigid winters and how to ride bareback. Elders of his tribe also helped him overcome fear in the pursuit of bravery and taught him to hunt. Medicine Crow avidly devoured the legends of the great warriors who had come before him, warring against the Lakota and the Cheyenne.

A significant component of the traditional Crow warrior life involved completing "four feats of valor" (via ATI). These feats included aspects of traditional warfare like stealing horses and counting coups. Only by achieving these four acts did a warrior become a Plains war chief. But the Crow had long been confined to reservations, and inter-tribal warfare had ceased, making the fulfillment of this ancient tradition appear impossible.

White Man Runs Him gifted his step-grandson, Joe Medicine Crow, with intimate knowledge about his time scouting for Lieutenant Colonel George Armstrong Custer and the events that precipitated the U.S. military disaster on June 25 and 26, 1876, at the Little Bighorn. But his grandfather's firsthand account didn't jive with the official narrative (via PBS).

White Man Runs Him claimed Lieutenant Colonel George Armstrong Custer's men had been drinking that day and weren't battle-ready (via True West Magazine). He said Custer's Crow scouts warned him not to attack the village because of its vast size. Yet, Custer ignored them. White Man Runs Him's account proves far from the varnished presentation of movies like 1941's "They Died With Their Boots On," which spin the narrative into the American version of the 300 Spartans at Thermopylae. Ironically, Medicine Crow answered an ad for extras to appear in the Errol Flynn flick only to get turned away because of his step-grandfather's less-than-heroic take on the Lieutenant Colonel.

After all, during World War II, America wanted to flex its military might, not revisit a foolhardy expedition. But Medicine Crow would have the last laugh in 1965. As the last surviving person who benefited from a "direct oral account" of Custer's "Last Stand," Medicine Crow wrote a script of the events still used each year during the Battle of the Little Bighorn re-enactment in Hardin, Montana, as reported by the National Park Service.

Since the introduction of horses to the Plains by the Spanish, Crow warriors had gone through a series of four steps to become war chiefs, per Military. But achieving these feats seemed impossible once the tribes moved to reservations. These feats included leading a war party to victory, stealing the opposition's horse, taking an enemy combatant's weapon, and counting coups by touching a living, breathing opponent, as reported by the NPS.

Passing each of these traditional tests looked unattainable within the context of daily life in pre-war America. But the battlefields of Europe offered Joe Medicine Crow the opportunities he needed to become a celebrated war chief. His death-defying heroics would become the stuff of new legends.

They included counting coups on a German soldier he ran into in an alleyway during an attack on a German city; he managed to both disarm and capture the soldier. But the heroics didn't stop there. Medicine Crow led seven troops on a veritable suicide mission to secure dynamite from a destroyed American position. He then used the captured explosives to charge the enemy, blowing a hole in the Siegfried Line and the Nazi guns thwarting an American advance (via Mountain Home Air Force Base). Despite braving artillery fire, landmines, and overwhelming enemy numbers, Medicine Crow and his men came through without a scratch. Fate and courage helped Medicine Crow complete the first three "feats of valor" (via ATI) almost unintentionally, as reported by PBS.

With the end of the war in 1945, Joe Medicine Crow returned home triumphant (via Billings Gazette). As was the custom among his people, he recited his war deeds to the community, covering everything from his face-to-face encounter with a German soldier to his dash behind enemy lines to take horses. For the Crow, certain actions like touching a living enemy ranked more highly than killing, and so these stories brought him great prestige, per Plains Humanities.

But he gained more than a reputation through the retelling of his war experiences. The elders of Medicine Crow's tribe realized he had completed the "four feats of valor" (via ATI) necessary to gain entry to that distinguished group of individuals known as Plains war chiefs. According to Military, they honored him with this title, making him the last man of the Plains tribes to ever receive this tribute.

This war distinction acknowledged Medicine Crow's exemplary bravery and performance in warfare and recognized his leadership potential within the community. It would be just one of many awards and accolades that he would receive for his death-defying actions during World War II.

Although Joe Medicine Crow holds the distinction for being the last Crow warrior to achieve all "four feats of valor" (via ATI), another member of his family came about as close as you could get (via Billings Gazette). During the Vietnam War, Medicine Crow's nephew Carson Walks Over Ice managed three requirements while serving as a Green Beret, according to Dr. Herman J. Viola's "Reflections" podcast. He also wore two medallions blessed by others in the tribe that he believed shielded him in battle like his uncle.

As a Green Beret, he often got dropped behind enemy lines. Because the Viet Cong proved exceptional at identifying and killing commanding officers, Sergeant Walks on Ice removed his insignias in battle. Instead, he wore an eagle feather in netting on his helmet, identifying him to his troops. 

Like his Uncle Joe Medicine Crow, Walks on Ice sought to complete the "four feats of valor." But getting his hands on an enemy horse proved challenging. He carried a rope in his pocket just in case, but the opportunity to nab an equine never arrived. However, he did manage to capture a couple of war elephants loaded with guns and ammunition from an enemy combatant along the Ho Chi Minh Trail. Unfortunately, pachyderms didn't count, according to Crow elders. But the elders did give him credit for leading many successful war parties without losing a man.

Although Joe Medicine Crow received many honors for his warrior feats, he never romanticized battle in his academic work, as reported by the NPS. He said of the Battle of the Little Bighorn (and more generally war), "No One wins. Both sides lose. The Indians, so-called hostiles, won the battle of the day but lost their way of life. The worst enemies are ourselves."

A theme running throughout the work and actions of Medicine Crow was that of healing. What Medicine Crow did at the groundbreaking ceremony commemorating the Indian memorial at the Little Bighorn best exemplifies his beliefs. According to Historian Paul Andrew Hutton (in an interview with True West Magazine), while working on the advisory commission for the monument, Hutton and his fellow board members worked diligently to avoid using the name of Lieutenant Colonel George Armstrong Custer. They hoped to eradicate all traces of the controversial military commander.

But during the ceremony, Medicine Crow jumped up from the crowd in his full World War II regalia. He walked up to Leonard Bruguier, head of American Indian Studies at the University of South Dakota, who had just finished giving a speech. Declaring that he would sing a song of honor for Custer, Medicine Crow delivered the lyrics in Crow and English, bringing a generous infusion of reconciliation to the ceremony.